Sign up for the newsletter

Signup for the Newsletter

Complaints force Autodesk to alter 3ds Max subs offer

Thursday, August 9th, 2012 | Posted by Jim Thacker

Autodesk has been forced to modify a 3ds Max subscription incentive after a string of complaints that a key part of the update was only available to users of the company’s Entertainment Creation Suites.

New particle tools for suite subscribers
The developer announced the new Extension for 3ds Max 2013, which augments 3ds Max’s native particle system, at the start of Siggraph 2012.

The Extension includes three key features, two of which – the MassFX mParticles module and Advanced Data Manipulation toolset – are only available to users of the suites.

Only the third, the Cache Disk and Cache Selective operators, is available to users on regular subscriptions.

A string of complaints
The announcement prompted a string of complaints from users who felt that Autodesk had effectively introduced a ‘two-tier’ subscription policy: one tier for suite users, and one for ‘regular’ 3ds Max users.

One fairly typical comment on CG Talk read: “I’ve tried to look at this decision objectively but I can’t. There’s absolutely no way I can see this as anything other than a huge ‘F**k you’ to the majority of 3ds Max’s user base.”

Max-only subscribers now get Orbaz add-on
Autodesk moved quickly to modify the offer. Within 12 hours, the company’s Ken Pimentel had posted back to say that 3ds Max subscription customers would also receive Orbaz Technologies’ Particle Flow Tools Box2.

Orbaz has just signed a licensing and co-development deal with Autodesk over its Box2 and Box3 particle add-ons. According to Pimentel’s forum post:

“Autodesk has heard the concerns of customers and has decided that current subscription users of 3ds Max and 3ds Max Design (along with users of suites that contain those products) will receive the Box2 extension (in addition to what they can already download) no later than October 2012. We will release more information about the change in the coming weeks.”

“We will continue to make available the combination of Box2 and Box3 ONLY to ECS subscription customers. If you want Box3 from Autodesk, then you’ll need to be an ECS subscription customer to get it.”

Complaints slowing, for now
The announcement seems to have stemmed most of the complaints: at time of posting, the threads on CG Talk and similar forums were still growing, but very slowly.

However, as some users have noted, even the modified offer preserves the incentive to upgrade to the Entertainment Creation Suites from 3ds Max alone.

The suites, which also include MotionBuilder, Mudbox and Sketchbook Designer, and which may also include Softimage and Maya, cost between $2,000 and $4,500 more than 3ds Max alone.

In the CG Talk thread, Ken Pimentel comments that renewal rates for Autodesk subscriptions are rising. However, with the company currently in the process of raising its subscription prices, this seems an issue that is likely to recur in future.

Visit Autodesk online

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

5 responses to “Complaints force Autodesk to alter 3ds Max subs offer”

  1. HFnord said:

    To put this news in some kind of perspective: Softimage didn’t get any SAP/Extension this year, apparently because its developers were too busy working on SI 2014. I’m not saying that’s a bad thing, BTW.

    3:52 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

  2. Dave said:

    Time to buy a now-cheaper license of Houdini.

    11:04 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

  3. Kurt said:

    In the thread, Ken wrote, “There is a big difference between Box2 and Box3. I can see why you might use Box2, harder to see most people using Box3” as a response to keeping Box3 a benefit for the Entertainment Creation Suite (ECS) owners. Considering the bundle primarily includes modeling and animation tools, it’s no wonder Ken can’t envision most people using Box3 – he’s considering the WRONG people!

    PFlow is primarily used for VFX and the additional tools in the Creation Suite (excluding Softimage) bring nothing to the VFX pipeline. Softimage and PFlow don’t really work together, so why offer a powerful PFlow tool and limit it to ECS customers?

    I suppose what’s really upsetting is that Autodesk is trying to create different packages and subscription tiers for the same software. It’s not like the extensions can even be used in any of the other software. Also, those poor 3ds Max Design folk get the shaft even if they purchased Max through one of the many “Design” suites.

    1:29 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

  4. The invisible SIGGRAPH « Mylenium's Blog said:

    […] into a mini-Autodesk, the value for money ratio and customer appreciation is just still better if that little gem is any indication. Elsewhere nothing much has happened – Houdini got now more affordable, […]

    3:34 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

  5. dhdth said:

    I was so angry about it, I purchased Thinking Particle ! So Autodesk can do what they want, I don´t care anymore. An I will cancle my subscription this year. This is how people react when you want to press all the money out of them !

    8:47 am on Friday, August 24, 2012

Leave a Reply

© CG Channel Inc. All Rights. Privacy Policy.